A Firth of Fifth by Genesis
- NTSC DVD-5
This was an interesting edit. It is courageous in that it banks 100% on your ability to conjure up images to accompany the very clever, well acted out narrative. However, as much as I love novel cinematic approaches, trying to get through it with absolutely no visual cues was trying at times and only works for so long. My suggestion would be to include something in the future to anchor a cinematic audience, be it photos (like le jetee, the other short), animation, etc. All in all a good effort and an interesting story. Nice work.
Audio/Video Quality: 9
There isn't any video so erm...
Visual Editing: 9
Audio Editing: 10
Freakin' amazin'! I've listened to this stuff many, many times and didn't notice anything out of place.
It flows just as well in this short version as in the long version. Nice job.
Who wouldn't enjoy another 15 minutes spent in this universe. Some accompanying stills might have been nice, a bit like the illustrated H2G2, but not needed.
Please can we have some more H2G2 edits like this, condensing each series down to a bite-sized best of? :-)
Very amusing. The humor is perfectly intact, and the time travel story here fits together quite well.