Excellent work! There were a couple of things on the cutlist that I was iffy about, but while watching the movie I enjoyed it so much I barely even noticed what was missing or changed! I think I noticed some music bleed-through in the ferry sequence - while the choice of using Iron Man 3's theme was an excellent one, I think some of the original score can be heard slightly fighting for dominance, but I could have been mistaken. And I wish the video file was larger with a higher bitrate, but I feel like I'm one of the few who prefers giant downloads to preserve picture quality, so YMMV on that one.
There is something incredibly satisfying when you watch the fanedit of a film that you so desperately wanted to love but couldn't and then the fanedit allows for this to happen instead.The edits,despite being minimal add a lot of needed depth to the film and the Raimi trilogy scores used at the end simply elevate the film to another level.Easily my definitive version of homecoming and would highly recommend people to give this watch now just in preparation for FFH.
This is a very minimal fanedit, but the edits made still manage to improve the film, thus resulting in a more satisfying experience. I already love the Spider-Man: Homecoming that we got, but I do appreciate what Bobson goes for here and he pulls it all off with flying colors. Really loved this edit.
When I first saw Spider-Man: Homecoming when it came out on DVD/Blu-ray, I really really liked the movie and it was easily the best Spider-man since Sam Raimi's Spider-man 2, which is my favorite Spider-man movie and still remains to be my favorite.
But that's not to say that this movie has some flaws, like Peter not having any spider-sense or him not really facing consequences for his actions aside from Vulture finding out his identity and stuff like that. That being said, I really enjoyed this fan-edit and the Rescore of the rubble scene brought a tear to my eye. Overall a really great and enjoyable movie and there was barely anything that I noticed that was cut due to me watching the movie only like twice before I saw this fan-edit so yeah!!! Good Job!!!
Having loved what Bobson did with Homecoming, I couldn't wait to see their take o Spider-Man 3. Long story short, it's pretty darn great. While listed as an extended cut, there is a rejiggering of the narrative after MJ breaks up with Peter that actually feels natural, building up Peter's dependency on the black suit moreso than the original. And cutting to the James Brown montage after Peter threw a bomb in Harry's face? Sam Raimi would be proud.
There are some things I feel would better improve the narrative though. You could cut the scene where Harry gets his memory back, imply that he was faking it the while time and waiting for the time to strike. I'd also cut Harry attacking MJ and let her break up with Peter on her own terms, give her some agency and real inner turmoil. Some scenes could also be grouped together to help the pacing, like the crane and Brock at the Bugle could be placed before seeing MJ on Broadway, establishing characters sooner rather than later.
But, this is an extension of the pre-existing movie. Aside from a few shots that looked like they were in SD, this is great. If you have a soft spot for Spider-Man 3, I highly recommend this take.
Do you recommend this edit?
Thanks for your kind words, but I think this may have been directed towards my Spider-Man 3.1 review and not my Homecoming one