Excellent work! There were a couple of things on the cutlist that I was iffy about, but while watching the movie I enjoyed it so much I barely even noticed what was missing or changed! I think I noticed some music bleed-through in the ferry sequence - while the choice of using Iron Man 3's theme was an excellent one, I think some of the original score can be heard slightly fighting for dominance, but I could have been mistaken. And I wish the video file was larger with a higher bitrate, but I feel like I'm one of the few who prefers giant downloads to preserve picture quality, so YMMV on that one.
Bobson has taken one of my favorite Spider-Man movies and made it even better. Mainly small changes throughout just tightened up some of the humor that didn't land. I really liked the inclusion of the Elfman Spiderman theme. Fantastic work!
I don't have much to say about this edit, I'm a big fan of Homecoming, and I believe Homecoming is better than this. However, I do see the appeal of this edit, and still recommend checking it out as I think this edit accomplishes it's goals really well.
Besides some unfortunate audio issues, such as the low voice volume when Iron Man 3's theme plays, the editing is pretty great. I really enjoyed the getting rid of '8 years later', as well as the rearrangement of the final/credits scenes.
When I first saw Spider-Man: Homecoming when it came out on DVD/Blu-ray, I really really liked the movie and it was easily the best Spider-man since Sam Raimi's Spider-man 2, which is my favorite Spider-man movie and still remains to be my favorite.
But that's not to say that this movie has some flaws, like Peter not having any spider-sense or him not really facing consequences for his actions aside from Vulture finding out his identity and stuff like that. That being said, I really enjoyed this fan-edit and the Rescore of the rubble scene brought a tear to my eye. Overall a really great and enjoyable movie and there was barely anything that I noticed that was cut due to me watching the movie only like twice before I saw this fan-edit so yeah!!! Good Job!!!
It's been a few weeks since I saw this so the finer details escape me now but this is a very well done fanfix. It doesn't fix all the issues I had with Marvel's first Spidey offering but then again it would be about an hour long if I got my hands on it and would make little sense. The rescoring was very well done and incorporating Elfman's theme as Peter arose from the rubble at the climax was a nice touch. Nothing at fault editing wise and the cuts chosen all made sense and are done seamlessly.
Succinctly put if you had minor issues with the original version and Bobson's cutlist looks good this is the edit for you. My only lower mark would be cheifly for the enjoyment factor which is down to my view of the film itself being tarnished on subsequent viewings (initially I quite liked it).