So, I actually grabbed a copy of this on blu-ray and watched it for the first time in anticipation of watching this fan-edit. The rest of the MCU has benefited so much from the love of fan-editors, so I decided if I was going to bite the bullet and actually catch up with the MCU after writing it off after GotG2, going for the fan-edits was the way to go. Not disappointed. This movie was actually much better than I anticipated, but the fan-edit made it possibly my favorite Spider-Man movie. Like Bobson's other edits I have watched, the trims were just that, trims, but they shaped the movie into something much greater than it was at first glance. As usual, I saw nothing glaring from the editing side of things, but that is not my expertise. The story and the humor really popped, though, when given the TLC they deserved.
I don't have much to say about this edit, I'm a big fan of Homecoming, and I believe Homecoming is better than this. However, I do see the appeal of this edit, and still recommend checking it out as I think this edit accomplishes it's goals really well.
Besides some unfortunate audio issues, such as the low voice volume when Iron Man 3's theme plays, the editing is pretty great. I really enjoyed the getting rid of '8 years later', as well as the rearrangement of the final/credits scenes.
Excellent work! There were a couple of things on the cutlist that I was iffy about, but while watching the movie I enjoyed it so much I barely even noticed what was missing or changed! I think I noticed some music bleed-through in the ferry sequence - while the choice of using Iron Man 3's theme was an excellent one, I think some of the original score can be heard slightly fighting for dominance, but I could have been mistaken. And I wish the video file was larger with a higher bitrate, but I feel like I'm one of the few who prefers giant downloads to preserve picture quality, so YMMV on that one.
There is something incredibly satisfying when you watch the fanedit of a film that you so desperately wanted to love but couldn't and then the fanedit allows for this to happen instead.The edits,despite being minimal add a lot of needed depth to the film and the Raimi trilogy scores used at the end simply elevate the film to another level.Easily my definitive version of homecoming and would highly recommend people to give this watch now just in preparation for FFH.
This is a very minimal fanedit, but the edits made still manage to improve the film, thus resulting in a more satisfying experience. I already love the Spider-Man: Homecoming that we got, but I do appreciate what Bobson goes for here and he pulls it all off with flying colors. Really loved this edit.