This is one of the first fanedits I saw many years ago, and it made me realise how irritating the voiceover is in the original. I cannot watch Fight Club anymore, this edit is definitely superior for me. The AV quality isn't the best, and sometimes it's obvious the voiceover has been removed, but these are honestly minor gripes compared to the improvements this edit makes to the original.
No narration turns this movie into a completely different experience. It won't replace the 'original', but I'll be watching this version every so often whenever I'm in the mood to watch Fight Club again.
absolutely fantastic! it’s a thinking man’s fight club! such a different movie and in my opinion, in many ways much better than the theatrical release. as already pointed out, there are some weird spots that don’t work perfectly. doing some more editing would pull it all together… the abc=x segment, could have simply been cut. also, there are a few parts like “let me tell you about tyler durden”, that probably need to deleted or moved. personally i’m for cutting it, to keep more mystery about tyler.
so i give it:
5/5 for creativity and concept
3/5 for execution
thanks for sharing and i hope to see a second version of jack’s laryngitis!