As an Oz fan, I really enjoyed this edit. Gives the full arc of the Beacher storyline in the first season. Spotted just one awkward shot… Beacher having flashbacks in the hole. I’m sure it was a necessary recap in the show, being a series with multiple viewpoints, several storylines and all, but it felt unnecessary and repetitive in the movie as all the events were still fresh in the viewer’s mind. The end credits looked a bit raw, too, but the movie itself was 9/10 for me.
Grim, brutal, and unrelenting like the original, this is a story of one man’s descent into prison hell. The hardest job with a TV series fanedit is taking the “raw material”, which is a serial format, and giving it the shape and structure of a movie. Gatos has accomplished this admirably and Emerald City has a well crafted introduction, character development arc, and climax. Sometimes this means that plot threads and characters are introduced and then ignored, but on balance it is a good editing decision to tolerate some of that in order to make the scene selection and sequencing feel right.
Beecher’s story is more disturbing and repellant when consolidated this way, so the narration that gives variety and perspective to the story is welcome, and the timing and amount of narration is good. The cuts throughout the edit flow exceedingly well, and the edit creates a real sense of forward development, even though the episodic feel is not entirely removed. A thought provoking and fairly horrifying experience. 9/10.