This is masterfully done, hands down. While there are still things that are a bit cringe worthy, the source material cannot be overcome with that aspect… and that’s fine. However, the overall ambient theme of this edition is far superior to the original.
You achieved what you set out for. The action and no lame jokes. So this was an excellent edit. I still miss the video game shootout scene. That is what made the original good to me.
If you’re looking for what CBB did to Doom then you will enjoy this edit.