Review Detail
9.0 1 10
Overall rating
9.0
Audio/Video Quality
10.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Visual Editing
10.0
Narrative
7.0
Enjoyment
8.0
It's nice to see someone giving some love to The Edge of Destruction. I have a soft spot for this messy, shoehorned story.
For the most part, I think the added incidental music was appropriate and supplements the stock music well, although there were spots where quieter dialogue becomes harder to understand in the mix, since the source audio isn't great to begin with.
The edits are well done, maintaining the pacing of the story while still managing to tighten it a bit. Video quality is probably as good as can be expected given it's a 720 upscale of 1960s television and I didn't notice any artifacts.
That said, I'm not in full agreement with the cuts made. I guess I'm a fan of unhinged, overdramatic Susan too much that I miss some continuity.
This one is still a slow burn, even after editing down.
I have a great appreciation for what MusicEd is attempting here, and I will be watching more of the series as they come out.
For the most part, I think the added incidental music was appropriate and supplements the stock music well, although there were spots where quieter dialogue becomes harder to understand in the mix, since the source audio isn't great to begin with.
The edits are well done, maintaining the pacing of the story while still managing to tighten it a bit. Video quality is probably as good as can be expected given it's a 720 upscale of 1960s television and I didn't notice any artifacts.
That said, I'm not in full agreement with the cuts made. I guess I'm a fan of unhinged, overdramatic Susan too much that I miss some continuity.
This one is still a slow burn, even after editing down.
I have a great appreciation for what MusicEd is attempting here, and I will be watching more of the series as they come out.
User Review
Do you recommend this edit?
Yes
Format Watched?
Digital
H