Review Detail

9.7 5 10
FanMix March 17, 2018 2910
(Updated: March 26, 2018)
Overall rating
 
9.4
Audio/Video Quality
 
10.0
Visual Editing
 
10.0
Audio Editing
 
9.0
Narrative
 
10.0
Enjoyment
 
9.0
I initially saw this during the Christmas period, a short while before the edit was "officially" released. It was great fun to watch it then during "prime" season, but although I'm one of those who consider Die Hard to be a classic Christmas movie, to me it's also a film that can be enjoyed all the year round.

The premise is quite simple, and in a lot of ways doesn't involve any huge changes to the film; but then again, I believe that was the editor's intention. As I believe Sinbad has stated, Diehard is one of his favourite films, and his main goal was simply to put a different spin on things and not make any drastic changes to the narrative. I believe he has succeeded in this. It still very much feels like the Die Hard you know, only with a more real-time feel. The side-by-side scenes flow wonderfully well, successfully creating a pacing more akin to the 24 TV series. I believe the editor struck the balance just right, putting in enough of these changes to create a different experience, but not so many that the new transitions come across as intrusive. The classic 24 ticking clock is also masterfully and sparingly used, adding an extra element of expectation and anticipation during key moments in the film.

Quality was top-notch, my only qualms being with things that are inherent in the source blu-ray, and therefore no fault of the editors.

Visual editing was flawless, as far as I could tell. Although the premise is simple, I imagine that getting it to work in practice was pretty challenging at times. Titles and added "24" style fonts also blended well.

Audio is nearly as excellent, especially considering what the editor has needed to achieve. The balance between audio on the scenes running side-by-side is a hard thing to perfect, and for the most part is spot on. There are times where audio from one scene can overpower another slightly, but I believe the editor has done the best he can to refine this. Action scenes are sooooo much louder than the rest of the film, but this, once again is a problem inherent in the source material. However, I believe that if the editor wanted to spend more time on it, he could probably make the decibel leap between scenes a little less shell shocking.

The narrative is fine in the original film, and remains unhindered in this version. Scenes run side-by-side, but the editor has wisely picked moments in the film where it is not vital for the viewer to be paying attention to both simultaneously.

Enjoyment is down a point, but it's chiefly subjective. I can't say that I LOVE Die Hard, but I do think it's a good film. For me, the original is 8/10, and I've added an extra point because I really enjoyed what the new "24" spin added. The only thing remaining being that I felt that the film could do with a tiny bit more streamlining. 12 minutes have already been removed, almost purely due to the nature of the edit (many of the scenes now running side by side), but despite there being a more "accelerated" and "real-time" feel, the film still doesn't feel quite as tight to me as it could be. If I would change anything, I would literally just do a handful of minor trims here and there, because for me there are sections of the movie that drag ever so slightly. Then again... I may have just forgotten to take my "B+" hat off ;)

In conclusion, a great edit of a good film. Unique, refreshing and clearly done with a high respect for the source material. It's great to finally see it on IFDB, and I hope to see it garner more attention once we hit December.
T
Top 100 Reviewer 41 reviews
Report this review Was this review helpful? 1 0

Comments

2 results - showing 1 - 2
Ordering
April 09, 2018
Thank you for the very detailed review!
S
sinbad
April 11, 2018
In reply to an earlier comment

You are most welcome!
T
the-scribbling-man
2 results - showing 1 - 2