Review Detail
8.8 7 10
(Updated: August 31, 2012)
Overall rating
8.8
Audio Editing
8.0
Visual Editing
9.0
Narrative
10.0
Enjoyment
8.0
I always kind of preferred BW2 to the first film, despite obvious flaws. Listening to the director’s commentary actually made me like it a little less though, as I lamented the version of the film we didn’t get.
Thankfully, we finally do have it in the form of steFAN’s edit. Maybe not exactly what the director would have released if given the chance, but as close as you can possibly get with the material released.
Job well done on this one. Apart from a…questionable audio transition near the beginning and spelling the director’s name wrong (twice) there was very little to complain about. I didn’t care for two song choices, but that’s just personal taste, and hardly the kind of thing to hold against the edit.
Special mention goes to the finale, which was reworked very nicely.
Thankfully, we finally do have it in the form of steFAN’s edit. Maybe not exactly what the director would have released if given the chance, but as close as you can possibly get with the material released.
Job well done on this one. Apart from a…questionable audio transition near the beginning and spelling the director’s name wrong (twice) there was very little to complain about. I didn’t care for two song choices, but that’s just personal taste, and hardly the kind of thing to hold against the edit.
Special mention goes to the finale, which was reworked very nicely.
U