Review Detail
8.4 16 10
Overall rating
8.9
Audio/Video Quality
9.0
Visual Editing
9.0
Audio Editing
10.0
Narrative
8.0
Enjoyment
9.0
March 2, 2009
ok so i’m going to mostly agree with boon and actually disagree with mollo (but, funny enough… both gave this 4/5 :) )
this is a great edit. the excised choices really boost the psychological horror here. VERY uncomfortable. i enjoyed the heavily cut introduction and conclusion and the way that the *climax* is handled leaves your imagination to fill in the gaps – which is quite disturbing.
some nitpicking… i think that removing the boys entirely would work better and jump straight to our unlucky couple at the beginning. also, as boon said, the “psychos playing with their prey” got a wee bit old and this could have been shortened for greater impact. also, the “This is a REAL story” revelation could add an even bigger mindf*ck at the end.
regardless, this was thoroughly “enjoyable” (that seems wrong) and felt like a much improved edit.
entertainment 9
fanediting 9
video 9
audio 10
original 7
fanedit 8
8/10
ok so i’m going to mostly agree with boon and actually disagree with mollo (but, funny enough… both gave this 4/5 :) )
this is a great edit. the excised choices really boost the psychological horror here. VERY uncomfortable. i enjoyed the heavily cut introduction and conclusion and the way that the *climax* is handled leaves your imagination to fill in the gaps – which is quite disturbing.
some nitpicking… i think that removing the boys entirely would work better and jump straight to our unlucky couple at the beginning. also, as boon said, the “psychos playing with their prey” got a wee bit old and this could have been shortened for greater impact. also, the “This is a REAL story” revelation could add an even bigger mindf*ck at the end.
regardless, this was thoroughly “enjoyable” (that seems wrong) and felt like a much improved edit.
entertainment 9
fanediting 9
video 9
audio 10
original 7
fanedit 8
8/10
J